Hanworth Villa FC

Hanworth Villa FC

Away | 16 August 2025

Soul Tower Hamlets 3 – 2 Hanworth Villa First

By | Ervin Ang

Villa suffer early FA Cup exit

An action-packed FA Cup classic saw Hanworth Villa exit the competition in the Preliminary Round after a surprise 3-2 defeat to Step 5 team Soul Tower Hamlets.

Villa took the lead early on through George Wells, but relinquished it after a brace from Sherman Artmeladze, although Sam Merson levelled for us in the second half. Fifteen minutes from time, Jason Hallet put a dagger in Villa’s hearts to seal a shock cup upset for the side playing in the Essex Senior League.

We last faced Tower Hamlets, then known as Bethnal Green United, in 2012 during the FA Cup’s Extra Preliminary Round and beat them 5-1 in a replay. A season earlier, Villa made it to the fourth qualifying round before losing 3-2 to AFC Totton. It was the furthest we ever progressed in the competition.

Manager Simon Haughney said: "Gutted, genuinely gutted to have gone out of the FA Cup the first time of asking. It's going to hurt (for me) and the players. They're quiet mouses in there, because they know that's not acceptable.

"Let's give credit to Soul Tower Hamlets, they've come here looking to upset us, they've upset us and they deserve to go through. First half we were passive and it wasn't good enough. We can't keep relying on these second half performances.

“I'm not making excuses, we've got to look at ourselves. It's all on me, I'll own it. I've got an uncomfortable conversation with the chairman later who's on holiday, he's not going to be happy with that and rightfully so.”

Haughney, serving the last match of his two-game touchline suspension, made two changes to last week’s team with defender Guy Hollis coming in to make his competitive Villa debut and Rayan Djouadj replacing Brandon Curtis in midfield.

At the Mile End Stadium, disaster nearly struck just 30 seconds after kick off against the home team. Artmeladze broke free from his marker and fired an effort against the crossbar, before Hallet put the rebound wide with Mark Smith still scrambling to get back into position.

With the pitch not in the most favourable condition, the linesman appeared to have rolled his ankle and required treatment just three minutes into the game. After a five-minute delay though, play resumed with the lino getting a huge cheer from both sets of fans as he got back onto his feet.

“In the next five minutes, someone’s gonna score. Concentration levels will drop after this stoppage in play,” said Haughney, observing from the stands. Who’s to doubt our wise manager who got it absolutely spot on!

Villa took the lead in the ninth minute, after the home side failed to deal with a set piece, allowing the ball to bounce inside the box, and Wells chested the loose ball down and fired it into the bottom corner.

Just when it looked like Villa were on the ascendency, a defensive lapse allowed Tower Hamlets back into the game in the 22nd minute. A blisteringly quick Rian Patel raced down the middle of the pitch before squaring for Artmeladze to tap home their equaliser into an empty net.

Past the half hour mark, Villa were forced into an early substitution as striker Dylan Randall came on to replace wing-back Marco Correia. Randall almost made an immediate impact off the bench in the 39th minute. But after expertly timing his run to beat the offside trap and be one-on-one with the goalkeeper, he pulled his left-footed finish wide.

Three minutes later, Josh Casey thought he had restored Villa’s advantage but his close range volley, after Wells’ free kick struck the wall, went agonisingly wide. Wells again went close from a Guy Hollis long throw in the seventh minute of first-half stoppage time, but his header was pushed clear by Amarildo Cerkezi.

It proved to be a decisive moment, as Tower Hamlets launched a counter attack from the loose ball and one long pass forward later, Artmeladze was racing clear towards Smith’s goal. The Georgian winger lobbed Smith with a well-taken finish to give the home team a shock lead at the interval.

Four minutes after the restart, Tower Hamlets were awarded a dubious penalty after the referee deemed Wells had handled Artmeladze’s flick inside the area, despite replays showing the ball clearly came off his shoulder.

With the game on the line, Smith read Artmeladze’s body language to perfection, guessing the right way and he dived low to his right to not only save, but hold onto the penalty to deny Artmeladze his hat-trick. It proved to be a huge turning point in the match.

Buoyed by the penalty save, Villa upped our tempo and there was a visible shift in momentum which we capitalised on in the 52nd minute. Merson opened his account for the season with a thunderous volley into the top corner past a stunned Cerkezi.

Haughney said: “Smudge is a great character. He's one that I don't have to worry about. You know, the standards he sets himself and why he's here, and he's kept us in it with a good penalty save.”

But there was another twist to the tale. Villa were again caught out on the transition in the 76th minute as the ball found it’s way to Hallet on the edge of the box from the right flank. He set himself up well for a first-time volley with his left footed effort arrowed into the bottom corner to give Tower Hamlets a 3-2 lead.

Haughney added: “We concede the goal, and then we get desperate. They're sitting deep and it's a pitch with the athletics track around, it does stop and start the game. We said today that we didn't want to fall behind in today's fixture. We did at 2-1, got back into it but then to concede the third, we were always going to be chasing it.”

It was an advantage they held on to despite a barrage of late Villa pressure, meaning our FA Cup journey came to an early end. There is still hope in the cup competitions for Villa though, as next up for Villa is a short trip to Hillingdon to face Northwood FC in the FA Trophy on August 23. Kick off is at 3pm.